Shame and guilt are emotions that some people experience during addiction and recovery. They may develop from past decisions, strained relationships, difficult experiences, or the way a person views themselves because of their substance use.
Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) is a structured therapy that may help people address distressing memories and negative beliefs connected with these emotions.
By working through experiences that contribute to self-blame or feelings of worthlessness, EMDR may support a more balanced understanding of the past.
Although EMDR is not specifically designed to eliminate shame or guilt, therapists commonly use it to address emotional difficulties associated with trauma, addiction, and other experiences.
Research suggests that it can help reduce certain forms of trauma-related guilt and shame, although its specific effects on addiction-related shame require further investigation.
What Is the Difference Between Shame and Guilt in Addiction?
Shame and guilt are closely related, but they involve different ways of thinking about experiences and behavior.
Guilt generally involves feeling that a particular action or decision was wrong. For example, someone may feel guilty about missing an important family event because of alcohol use or behaving in a way that affected another person.
Shame is more closely connected to how someone views themselves. Rather than thinking, "I made a mistake," a person experiencing shame may believe, "I am a bad person."
This distinction matters because guilt can sometimes encourage people to recognize mistakes and make positive changes. Shame, particularly when it becomes persistent, may contribute to self-criticism, withdrawal, and difficulty seeking support.
Research published in Addictive Behaviors discusses how guilt and shame can influence addiction recovery differently.
The authors explain that guilt may support constructive changes when it encourages responsibility, while shame may make recovery more difficult when it becomes connected with a person's overall sense of self.
However, these emotions are complex, and people do not experience them in the same way.
Why Do People Experience Shame and Guilt During Addiction?
Shame and guilt can develop for several reasons, and their intensity varies from person to person.
Some people feel regret about decisions made while using substances. Others experience negative reactions from family members, friends, or society that influence how they see themselves.
Common experiences associated with addiction-related shame and guilt include:
Regret about actions taken while using alcohol or drugs.
Concern about how substance use has affected relationships.
Feeling disappointed about previous attempts to reduce substance use.
Negative beliefs about personal worth or abilities.
Experiencing judgment or stigma because of addiction.
Difficult memories associated with past substance use.
For some individuals, earlier traumatic experiences may also contribute to feelings of shame or self-blame.
For example, someone who experienced childhood neglect or abuse may already have developed negative beliefs about themselves before substance use began.
These beliefs may continue to influence emotional responses during addiction and recovery.
Not everyone with addiction experiences significant shame or guilt, and these emotions are not necessarily caused by trauma.
How Can Shame and Guilt Affect Addiction Recovery?
Shame and guilt can influence motivation, emotional well-being, and the way people approach recovery.
Guilt about a particular behavior may sometimes encourage someone to repair a relationship or make a different decision.
Shame can be more complicated.
When a person begins to believe that their mistakes define who they are, they may find it difficult to recognize their strengths or imagine positive changes.
Some individuals may also use alcohol or drugs to temporarily manage uncomfortable emotions, including shame.
This can contribute to a pattern in which substance use leads to regret, regret increases emotional discomfort, and substance use becomes a familiar way of coping.
However, this pattern does not occur for everyone.
A 2025 study published in the European Journal of Psychotraumatology examined people receiving treatment for substance use disorders who had experienced traumatic events.
Researchers found that shame and emotional avoidance were associated with greater difficulties managing emotions, even after accounting for post-traumatic stress symptoms.
These findings suggest that addressing shame may be relevant to addiction treatment, particularly for people who also experience trauma-related difficulties.
The study was observational, so it did not establish that shame directly causes substance use or problems with emotional regulation.
How Might EMDR Help With Addiction-Related Shame and Guilt?
EMDR helps people process distressing memories and experiences using a structured therapeutic approach.
During EMDR, a person focuses on selected aspects of a memory while engaging in bilateral stimulation, often through guided eye movements.
The process is designed to help reduce distress associated with memories and support more balanced beliefs about past experiences.
When shame or guilt is connected with particular memories, EMDR may help a person reconsider the meaning they attach to those experiences.
Several aspects of EMDR are especially relevant.
1. Addressing Distressing Memories
Some feelings of shame or guilt are connected to specific events.
For example, someone may repeatedly think about an argument, a decision made while using substances, or an experience in which they felt judged or rejected.
Even after circumstances change, these memories may continue to influence emotional responses.
EMDR can focus on the memories contributing to current distress.
As processing takes place, some people notice that they can remember an event without experiencing the same level of emotional discomfort.
The goal is not to erase the memory or change what happened. Instead, it is to help the experience become less emotionally disruptive.
2. Working With Negative Beliefs About the Self
Shame is often connected with negative personal beliefs.
A person may develop thoughts such as:
"I am not good enough."
"I always make mistakes."
"I do not deserve forgiveness."
"I cannot change."
"My past defines who I am."
These beliefs may have developed through addiction-related experiences, earlier trauma, or repeated criticism.
EMDR includes attention to negative beliefs associated with distressing memories.
During processing, a person may begin to consider more balanced perspectives, such as recognizing that a past decision does not determine their entire identity.
This does not mean ignoring personal responsibility. Rather, it involves developing a clearer and more compassionate understanding of oneself.
3. Reducing Emotional Distress Associated With Guilt
Guilt can sometimes remain emotionally uncomfortable even after someone has acknowledged a mistake or attempted to make amends.
For example, a person may continue revisiting a past event and experiencing regret long after the situation has changed.
EMDR may help reduce the emotional intensity associated with these memories.
This can create room for a person to consider what they have learned and how they want to move forward.
Importantly, EMDR does not aim to remove appropriate feelings of responsibility.
The distinction is between learning from an experience and remaining caught in repeated, unhelpful self-blame.
4. Supporting More Balanced Self-Perceptions
Some people experiencing addiction begin to view themselves primarily through the difficulties associated with their substance use.
Their attention may become focused on previous mistakes rather than their current efforts, abilities, and relationships.
By addressing distressing memories and negative beliefs, EMDR may help some individuals develop a more balanced view of themselves.
For example, someone who previously believed that past substance use made positive change impossible may gradually become more open to the possibility of recovery.
These changes are individual and cannot be guaranteed.
What Does Research Say About EMDR, Shame, and Guilt?
Research has examined how EMDR affects trauma-related shame, guilt, negative beliefs, and other emotional concerns.
A randomized clinical trial published in The British Journal of Psychiatry in 2020 compared EMDR with imagery rescripting, another trauma-focused treatment, for adults experiencing post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) related to childhood trauma.
Both treatments were associated with reductions in trauma-related shame, guilt, and negative beliefs.
The researchers did not find meaningful overall differences between the two treatments.
These findings support the use of EMDR for addressing emotional difficulties connected with traumatic memories, including shame and guilt.
More recently, a randomized trial involving 209 people with co-occurring PTSD and substance use disorders examined trauma-focused treatments, including EMDR, alongside addiction care.
A 2026 analysis reported improvements in several areas of psychological and social functioning when EMDR or imagery rescripting was added to substance use treatment. The outcomes examined included trauma-related shame and guilt, emotional regulation, and psychological distress.
The findings support the potential value of addressing trauma-related concerns during addiction treatment. However, they do not establish that EMDR consistently reduces addiction-specific shame or guilt for everyone.
Earlier research has also produced mixed findings.
For example, a small 2014 pilot study involving 12 people receiving treatment for alcohol or drug dependence found improvements in trauma symptoms and certain emotional measures when EMDR was added to usual treatment. The study did not find a significant improvement in addiction symptoms.
Taken together, the research suggests that EMDR can be useful for trauma-related emotional concerns, including negative self-beliefs and some experiences of shame or guilt. More research is needed to determine its specific effects on shame and guilt arising directly from addiction.
What Did the Virtual EMDR Study Find About Self-Blame?
The Virtual EMDR self-guided study provides additional information about how participants perceived changes in negative beliefs and self-blame.
In the 2025 Virtual EMDR Platform Effectiveness Analysis — Phase 2: Initial Findings, participants were asked whether they blamed themselves less for events related to their trauma after using the program.
Among the 315 survey participants:
19% strongly agreed that they experienced less trauma-related self-blame.
42% agreed that their self-blame had decreased.
27% selected a neutral response.
12% disagreed or strongly disagreed.
The average response was 3.60 on a five-point scale.
The report also found that 64% of respondents agreed or strongly agreed that they found it easier to challenge negative beliefs about themselves or the world.
These findings suggest that many participants perceived positive changes in self-blame and self-related beliefs.
However, the results were based on participants' self-reported experiences. They do not establish that the program caused these changes, and the survey did not specifically measure addiction-related shame or guilt.
The findings are therefore relevant to understanding how EMDR may relate to self-blame, but they cannot be used as direct evidence that self-guided EMDR reduces shame or guilt associated with addiction.
What Happens During EMDR When Shame or Guilt Is a Concern?
EMDR follows a structured process that begins with understanding the experiences and concerns a person wants to address.
When shame or guilt is relevant, the process may involve identifying memories associated with negative self-beliefs.
For example, someone may choose to focus on a memory connected with regret, rejection, or feeling inadequate.
During EMDR, attention is given to the memory, the emotions associated with it, and the beliefs the person holds about themselves.
Bilateral stimulation is then used as part of the memory-processing procedure.
As the process continues, some people notice changes in how they understand the experience.
A memory that previously reinforced the belief "I am a failure" may become associated with a more balanced understanding, such as "I made mistakes, but I can learn and change."
These examples illustrate possible changes rather than outcomes everyone will experience.
EMDR may involve less detailed verbal discussion of past experiences than traditional talk therapy, although the amount of discussion varies.
The process can be adapted to the person's concerns and goals.
Can EMDR Be Combined With Other Approaches to Address Shame and Guilt?
Yes. EMDR can be included alongside other approaches that help people manage addiction and develop healthier ways of responding to difficult emotions.
For example, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) may help individuals recognize self-critical thoughts and develop more balanced thinking patterns.
Compassion-focused approaches may support a kinder and more constructive relationship with oneself.
Peer support and recovery groups may also help reduce isolation by providing opportunities to connect with others who understand addiction-related experiences.
When trauma-related memories contribute to shame or guilt, EMDR may address those memories while other approaches focus on current behaviors, coping strategies, and recovery goals.
These methods can complement one another.
The most useful combination depends on the individual and the concerns they want to address.
Does Addressing Shame Mean Ignoring Responsibility?
No. Reducing shame does not mean denying that past actions may have affected other people.
A person can acknowledge mistakes, accept responsibility, and work toward making changes without defining their entire identity through those experiences.
This distinction is particularly important in addiction recovery.
For example, someone may recognize that their substance use affected a relationship while also understanding that they are capable of making different choices.
Addressing unhelpful self-blame may make it easier to approach past experiences with greater clarity.
EMDR may support this process when emotional distress or negative beliefs are connected with particular memories.
The aim is not to change the facts of the past, but to help people develop a more balanced relationship with those experiences.
Can Shame and Guilt Improve During Addiction Recovery?
Yes. Feelings of shame and guilt can change as people develop new perspectives, build supportive relationships, and make progress toward their recovery goals.
For some individuals, these changes may happen through reflection, counseling, or improved circumstances.
Others may find it useful to address particular memories or negative self-beliefs through EMDR or another therapeutic approach.
Progress does not require completely eliminating every uncomfortable feeling about the past.
Guilt can sometimes remain useful when it encourages accountability and constructive action.
What matters is whether those emotions help a person move forward or repeatedly contribute to self-criticism and distress.
A more balanced understanding of past experiences can be an important part of emotional well-being during recovery.
Final Thoughts
Shame and guilt can affect how people view themselves, respond to difficult memories, and approach addiction recovery.
EMDR may help address these emotions when they are connected with distressing experiences, negative self-beliefs, or trauma-related memories.
Research supports EMDR's ability to reduce certain forms of trauma-related guilt and shame, while studies involving people with substance use disorders suggest potential benefits from combining trauma-focused treatment with addiction care.
However, evidence specifically demonstrating that EMDR reduces addiction-related shame and guilt remains limited.
For people whose past experiences contribute to self-blame or feelings of worthlessness, EMDR may offer a way to process those memories and develop more balanced perspectives.
Understanding that past actions and personal identity are not the same can also support a more constructive approach to recovery.
References
Snoek, A., McGeer, V., Brandenburg, D., & Kennett, J. (2021). Managing shame and guilt in addiction: A pathway to recovery. Addictive Behaviors, 120, 106954.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.addbeh.2021.106954Boterhoven de Haan, K. L., et al. (2020). Imagery rescripting and eye movement desensitisation and reprocessing as treatment for adults with post-traumatic stress disorder from childhood trauma: Randomised clinical trial. The British Journal of Psychiatry.
https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.2020.158Difficulties in emotion regulation among patients with substance use disorder and a history of exposure to traumatic events: The role of PTSD symptoms, emotional avoidance, shame, and guilt. (2025). European Journal of Psychotraumatology.
https://doi.org/10.1080/20008066.2025.2509385Effects of timing and type of trauma-focused treatment on psychosocial functioning: Secondary outcomes from a randomized controlled trial in patients with co-occurring substance use disorder and posttraumatic stress disorder. (2026).
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42054900/Treating Trauma in Addiction with EMDR: A Pilot Study. (2014). Journal of Psychoactive Drugs.
https://doi.org/10.1080/02791072.2014.921744Strategic Voyages Business Consultants. (2025). Virtual EMDR Platform Effectiveness Analysis — Phase 2: Initial Findings. Prepared by Matt Wilhelmi, May 21, 2025. Sections 12 and 13, including pages 63–68 on negative beliefs, self-blame, and cognitive changes.